FACHEP vs. The People of the State of Michigan: Part IX One Day of Unfiltered Love

The Big Picture

Flintwaterstudy launched July 2015 to “help resolve scientific uncertainties associated with drinking water issues being reported in the City of Flint, MI.” We worked overtime to expose the depths of the Flint Water Crisis in terms of lead, legionella and unethical government behavior—a Federal Emergency was declared January 2016.

The resulting international media sensation and $600+ million in relief funding accomplished great good but also created powerful corrupting influences. A peer-reviewed paper Citizen Science During the Flint, Michigan Federal Water Emergency: Ethical Dilemmas and Lessons Learned published last week describes some gut-wrenching issues encountered in 2016-2018, and our attempts to address them.

About a year ago we launched this investigative science blog series, to shed light on the felony cases against Dr. Eden Wells and Mr Nick Lyon. At the time wrote about a presumption of guilt and perjury concerns as follows:

 “In late September 2015, we wrote that some MDHHS employees were behaving unethically, but within a few days MDHHS reversed course by agreeing the water was unsafe, and after Dr. Wells started working with us in December 2015, we were impressed enough to call her out publicly in a good way on our webpage on January 7, 2016. Ever since, Michigan government has supported our scientific work and professionally answered all our questions, even when they were fully aware our research was showing that the switch to Flint River water was one key factor contributing to the Legionnaires’ Disease outbreak and associated deaths. We published two peer-reviewed journal papers documenting this science in 2016 and 2017At no point did anyone at MDHHS or the governor’s office discourage or impede our teams ground-breaking research that helped reveal the Flint Legionella outbreak.

Given our own positive experiences with MDHHS since December 2015, we were surprised when professors representing the Flint Area Community Health and Environment Partnership (FACHEP) alleged under oath that the State of Michigan had not cooperated with their Legionella research. Indeed, sworn testimony by FACHEP professors was a basis for felony “obstruction of justice” charges against Wells and Lyons. To date, the media has generally sided with the presumably noble FACHEP professors and against the maligned state employees in all such disputes.  Starting with this article, Flintwaterstudy will present an investigative series that calls that narrative into question…”

We are publicly blowing the whistle on our colleagues in this blog series because a miscarriage of justice might result if we were to remain silent. That injustice involves not just the lives of Dr. Wells and Mr. Lyon, but also the historical record of government achievement during the Flint Disaster response—it involves the commodity of public-trust, of which there is precious little in present day Flint. We blow the whistle not because it is easy or will be rewarded, but because it is hard and righteous. As Dr. Edwards correctly predicted to the Detroit News “…I fully expect to pay a professional price for upholding my responsibilities.”

When asked if he felt naïve about the later efforts to destroy his professional reputation, Edwards told the Washington Post: “It comes down to duty versus self-preservation….In a post-truth world, science has become just another weapon of tribal warfare, and rising above that takes courage.” We do fear for the fate of our world, if university professors go Post-truth.

Paraphrasing Winston Churchill, some might ask: “What is our aim?” To answer in one word, it is TRUTH.  Truth with a capital T. Truth, in spite of ourselves. Truth, with all its warts, human frailty, and soul-sickening unethical behavior. For without truth, as was tragically illustrated during the Flint Water Crisis and its aftermath… we will all sink into the abyss of a new dark age made more sinister, and perhaps more protracted, by the lights of perverted science.”


Part IX: One Day of Unfiltered Love

(December 14, 2016 – December 15, 2016) 

An investigative science reporting series by Flintwaterstudy.org

Part 8 ended with FACHEP falsely assuring project manager Dr. Eden Wells (MDHSS) that the forthcoming December 14th, 2016 public meeting at the Flint Library would present nothing new, even as they prepared a presentation that would scare Flint residents and portray the State of Michigan unfavorably.

Dr. Ben Pauli (Kettering) later admitted that the purpose of the meeting was “to roll out <FACHEP> preliminary results directly to residents,” “winning over” the activists “who saw the state <of MI> as their number-one enemy” by emphasizing possible dangers of Flint water. FACHEP also figured that the story about bacteria, offered “hopeofimpeding the rush to declare the crisis over.

Let’s imagine ourselves in Dr. Wells’ shoes at 5 am the morning after the Flint library meeting, as she learned about media coverage, social media fallout, and FACHEPs sidebar conversations with residents. Illustrative snippets of each are provided below.

MEDIA COVERAGE. Although McElmurry told Wells no media would be invited, they attended and had a field day. Mlive ran a story with Dr. Love’s proclamation that it was important to flush the filtersat least one minuteto clear away dangerous bacteria and that residents should also be “boiling water or using a UV disinfection lamp” to treat filtered water. Her claims contradicted 11-13 months of unified messaging (FEMA, United Way, National Guard, ATSDR, EPA, GCHD, MDEQ, MDHSS, CDC, City of Flint, and FlintWaterStudy) that it was ok to directly drink POU filtered Flint water.

Photo of Dr. Love at Flint library purchased from Mlive

Mlive also quoted Melissa Mays, who was collaborating with FACHEP on an effort to create a narrative Flint water was getting worse:

“It was nice to hear that things aren’t all better… I can only imagine what would happen if I were to try to drink this through the tap filters. It’s telling me I’m making the right decision by drinking bottled water.”

FACHEP leader McElmurry expressed a self-promotional worldview, that no one else working on the FWC could possibly care for Flint residents, like “Wayne Cares for Flint.” 

it’s important that Flint residents know “that there are people out there working to understand the concerns that residents have.”

WNEM Channel 5 trumpeted “WATER SAMPLES REVEAL PROBLEM FOR FLINT RESIDENTS,” quoting Dr. Zervos (WSU):  “There’s issues with the point of use filters….bacteria levels actually increase… for bacteria there’s an issue.” Mr. Quincy Murphy, an activist who was on FACHEP’s payroll, stated “…the preliminary test results confirm many residents’ fears…. We just keep getting the run around and these people telling us it’s OK…we don’t know who to trust and who to believe.”

SOCIAL MEDIA. A selection of some social media quotes poignantly illustrate that Dr. Love’s presentation had a significant impact, including planting the idea that Flint residents were being used in a sort of unethical and uncontrolled human experiment.

Dr. Sullivan, acting in her role of “restoring trust” between Flint residents and the State of Michigan, unleashed a volley of FACHEP propaganda. She electronically high-fived Dr. Zervos for speaking out” about the dangerous bacteria, inexplicably damned the State of Michigan for a “deluge of darkness that makes us afraid” and lauded McElmurry for navigating a “storm of voices that say that Flint residents aren’t able to handle the truth about their water.”

SIDEBAR CONVERSATIONS. Dr. Pauli wrote that at the beginning of the Flint library meeting, “I could tell we would have our work cut out for us winning <the activists> over. FACHEP worked overtime and pulled out all the stops after the formal presentation was over. In sidebar conversations Dr. Zervos (WSU) asserted the State of Michigan were “cheap bastards” who would not come up with necessary funding for bacteria testing. There were obviously hard feelings that FACHEP was not provided the full $13 million McElmurry initially requested.

Dr. Pauli also continued FACHEP’s smear campaign against Dr. Edwards. Herein, we only cite rumors that can be independently verified in Dr. Pauli’s draft book chapter or recorded public presentations. First, there was a FACHEP manufactured lie, that on December 8th Edwards requested Dr. McElmurry sign a “sweeping” written declaration that Flint water was “safe.” When in reality, Edwards had merely requested a quote from McElmurry acknowledging Flint water was “much improved” compared to the height of the crisis 13 months earlier. Then there was a Dr. Love-inspired litany of alleged financial conflicts including that Dr. Edwards was “paid,” “bought,” “sold out” or “collaborating” with the State of MI.

Pauli introduced another strategic misquote, that Edwards had “claimed that Flint’s tap water, when filtered, was of a higher quality than bottled water!” His book cites an article from which the actual written quote was “Edwards said, properly filtered water in the city was likely as good, if not better, than bottled water, especially prepackaged water that had been stored for a long time in hot conditions.” We note that Dr. Pauli has publicly stated his work “is focused on…less the truth of the crisis with a capital T, and more of the struggle around the crisis,”..and that “sometimes when you are engaged in a process of struggle, truth is your ally, and sometimes it isn’t.” There is a clear pattern of FACEHP sacrificing truth to support their “struggle” of creating a hero narrative for themselves.

Not content with just verbal rumors, Pauli put exclamation points on alleged differences between FACHEP’s message about water safety, and the many false claims they made about Edwards, by tweeting: “The team is not ready to make a blanket statement about the water being safe”. And in the book chapter Pauli wrote, “at least we were not proclaiming the water “safe” at the meeting.

DR. LOVE UNFILTERED

How on earth can someone portray the free distribution of POU filters, that are purchased voluntarily by tens of millions of American each year to remove particles, tastes/odors, lead and organic chemicals, as an unprecedented, life-threatening, uncaring human experiment? More importantly, WHY would someone do that? We trace it back to Dr. Love’s deep-seated insecurities and jealousies, and a quest to make her mark as a heroine of the Flint water crisis one way or another. 

The die was cast in her initial January 2016 email to Dr. Edwards, where she acknowledged the POU filters were her only professional experience remotely relevant to the FWC. Yet, even on that narrow topic, she had never published a single peer reviewed paper, or bothered to learn details of the Flint filter deployment. In terms of drinking water expertise, Dr. Love was a zero-trick pony, destined to repeatedly take the microphone on the FWC stage, solemnly making a case about alleged dangers of POU filters, yet earning only politely suppressed jeers from true experts observing the spectacle while rejecting her illogical reasoning.

At the December 14, 2016 press conference, with no true experts in her way, Dr. Love would get her chance to take the microphone unfiltered. We even suspect that the false written statement to Dr. Wells that nothing new would be presented, was deliberate, to make sure no voices of scientific reason would intrude or otherwise bear witness to what FACHEP was doing.

The 18 pages of written talking points prepared days in advance of the library meeting, starts with ignorance of communicating molecular microbiology results to the public (i.e., SLOAN MOBE 101), builds on negligent false assumptions about the POU filter deployment in Flint, and ended with Love’s POU Flint filter “manifesto” with a predetermined conclusion set in concrete months earlier. There was a heavy emphasis on using the words “anomalous,” “abnormal,” and “unusual” to describe DNA detected in the Flint filters, and a repeated implication that filtered Flint water was probably dangerous for consumption without additional treatment (see summary of some talking points below).

THE FLINT LIBRARY MESSAGE ACCORDING TO DR. BEN PAULI

We cite Dr. Ben Pauli’s personal account of the tone and tenor of FACHEP’s message from his draft book chapter:

…some unexpected results were emerging from the point-of-use filter study: bacteria were growing in the filters that did not seem to belong there. …. bacteria associated with the mammalian gut (suggestive of some sort of fecal contamination), including species listed by the World Health Organization as being especially dangerous because of their resistance to antibiotics…. <Given t>he unforeseen discovery of potentially pathogenic bacteria, it seemed like <residents> were entitled to know about the findings while there was still time to take extra precautions, even though the results were preliminary and analysis ongoing.

Bursting Dr. Pauli’s bubble of fictitious drama, twenty-seven months later, FACHEP has still not published compelling data to support their claims about dangers of POU filtered water. In mid-2017, FACHEP admitted they still had no evidence of harmful bacteria or filter associated disease. As for the “unforeseen discovery of potentially pathogenic bacteria” and antibiotic resistance DNA, that was foreseeable by anyone who bothered to read a few papers about application of molecular methods to drinking water samples anywhere in the world. None of this should have been construed as unique to Flint POU filters.

Yet the most ridiculous parts of Dr. Love’s “story,” were implied black magical properties of POU filters installed only in Flint. First, there was a claim that in Flint, somehow the POU filters were recreating a warm, nutrient-rich ecosystem of a “mammalian gut,” thereby growing human fecal pathogens that would cause “Shigella-like disease” with “especially dangerous” antibiotic resistance. Or as Dr. Pauli wrote ominously, that Filter use in Flint was not…comparable to filter use elsewhere” and the situation was “abnormal.”

Second, was the illusion that mounting a POU filter to the end of a kitchen faucet in Flint, negated all upstream treatments and created a “single barrier” to dangerous bacteria (see slide). Love’s Flint library slide literally implies, that the filter installation, caused Detroit’s water treatment plants serving Flint to magically vanish (see page 3 of this link for descriptions of multibarrier bacteria treatments in Detroit). This was irresponsible.

Dr. Love also made no mention Flint was benefiting from enhanced chlorine dosing, enhanced corrosion control, and intense bacterial monitoring required by EPA in Flint from early 2016 onwards as implemented by relief agencies. No mention that legally-required coliform bacterial monitoring proved that there was highly effective bacteria control, with results so good, that coliform bacteria were undetectable in Flint water samples for 3 consecutive years.

Given all of the above, why was Dr. Love so focused on POU filter dangers in Flint?  Imagine what would have happened, if Dr. Love had held a press conference, articulating her fears that filtered Ann Arbor drinking water was so dangerous, her family had actually started boiling it before consumption. Or held a press conference, announcing that all 4 million consumers of Detroit water with POU filters (probably at least a million people), should also boil or UV treat their water, and not just the 0.1 million consumers receiving the same Detroit water (but with enhanced disinfection) in Flint. Of course, such assertions would have exposed Dr. Love as an alarmist crackpot. It was only in Flint, where FACHEP had carefully prepared the ground with 4 months of rumormongering, that such unbalanced claims could be taken seriously.

The takeaway message received by Flint residents who attended the meeting were that: 1) their lives may be in imminent danger, 2) Flint water treatment was grossly inadequate, 3) POU filters were providing only a “single barrier” of protection, 4) the “wrong” filters were selected by relief agencies, and 5) the filter itself was somehow turning good old Detroit water into mammalian excrement. It was therefore little surprise when one panicked resident called the State and askedif they were going to die because they were drinking out of the filters.” This logically built on Love and McElmurry’s proven track record in scaring residents like the Webbers, or the resident who literally abandoned her Flint home after talking with McElmurry.

DR. LOVE: IT IS MY FAULT

After a drive home, Dr. Love realized there may have been problems with how the presentation was delivered. She blamed her tendency to be “laser focused,”confessing:

“I don’t feel like I answered questions well, and didn’t say some of the things that were important to say…In the future, I will benefit from having a practice run on the presentation.  I don’t get nervous, but I get laser focused on a few things at the expense of everything else. There are times when my laser focus is beneficial, but this was not one of them.  Truly, I’ve been known to forget my name because I was so laser focused. Spending 2.5 hours with a red knuckle grip on the steering wheel coming up just primed my “laser focus” pump.”

McElmurry reassured Dr. Love that she “did great…. <and> it went about as good as could be expected.” He then proudly forwarded the WNEM story reporting how FACHEP was successful in destroying resident trust and creating needless fear about bacteria on the filters. The meeting was a grand success from the perspective of FACHEP’s leader and according to Dr. Pauli’s book.

DR. LOVE:  IT IS NOT MY FAULT

After Dr. Love’s fantastic story of mammalian gut feces hit Dr. Wells’ fan at 5 am the next day, everything had to be dropped by Dr. Wells to change FACHEP’s dirtied diapers yet again. Whatever humility Dr. Love expressed the night before, was replaced by a renewed “laser focus” to “deny responsibility, accuse and blame others, and maintain a facade of arrogance and conceit.”

Love emailed McElmurry that “from my point of view:

1. No new information was presented. Indeed, I held off on new information….

2. I remain perplexed how the information about the increase in bacteria across the filters is a surprise. Not only have we discussed this with them before, especially during the “you are going to release shigella data” kerfuffle, but did they not read ANY literature about filters before they decided to deploy 24,000 of them in Flint? Literature, papers, NSF Standards? Anything? This should not be a surprise and was the public health community’s responsibility when they decided to deploy an intervention that they do not understand.

3. I think I was balanced and measured and clear. Counts go up (not unusual for these filters) and we are looking at who those bacteria are. Again, this is absolutely not new. The only thing that is new is that the general public, not just those who we sampled, are now aware of what the state should have told citizens was a risk from the beginning.

This email reveals Dr. Love in full Dunning-Kruger glory. Based on 0 years of experience in drinking water public health crises, she constructs an alternate reality in which she is blameless, and all the relief agencies are incompetent and unethical. How dare the agencies not acknowledge Dr. Love as a great moral exemplar, engineering ethics philosopher, waterborne disease expert, and gifted risk communicator.

McElmurry then pounced on an opportunity to further gaslight Dr. Wells with another misrepresentation of reality: “I want to stress that no new information was presented…Overall, I think those that attended received the message and took it well. Obviously, we can’t control what others do with the information.”

Well, did FACHEP control the image of the multibarrier water treatment plant, disappearing after attaching a POU filter to a kitchen faucet? Did FACHEP control the message sent about the “cheap bastards” at the State of MI sponsoring their research? What about Dr. Sullivan’s “deluge of darkness that makes us afraid,” or FACHEP implying that filter use in Flint was unlike anything heretofore experienced in America?  And if Dr. Wells did not like it, well, then what—still more pointless pleading to FACHEP’s higher motives?

WHAT ON EARTH IS WRONG WITH FACHEP LEADERSHIP?

Still struggling for an explanation regarding FACHEP’s reckless unscientific behavior, even after all the mistakes exposed in Parts 1-8, we found information online consistent with an emerging pattern of behavior that gave rise to the FACHEP-instigated Wells and Lyon felony cases:

When caught in the act with their unscrupulous behavior, most sociopaths and psychopaths will not show signs of contrition or remorse… On the contrary, they are more likely to double or triple down on their aggressive tendencies, increase hostility, deny responsibility, accuse and blame others, and maintain a facade of arrogance and conceit. Interestingly, many sociopaths will invent a victimhood story for themselves:…Casting themselves as victims can help sociopaths and psychopaths to defend their immoral conduct.

While we are not psychologists and cannot render a diagnosis, we nonetheless consider the above helpful, in providing a plausible hypothesis for behavior of this quintessential team of academic crybullies.

And to think that all of the above was accomplished from just 24 hours of Dr. Love unfiltered. After her first public taste of FACHEP glory, Love and McElmurry laid plans for an extraordinarily productive month. Over the holidays, when most of the world was taking a break, FACHEP would be working overtime to “double and triple down” on the Flint POU filter manifesto and inventing an epic story of victimhood.

Supporting Documents:

FACHEP December 14 Press Conference Handout

FOIA Packet

Primary Author: Dr. Marc Edwards

8 thoughts on “FACHEP vs. The People of the State of Michigan: Part IX One Day of Unfiltered Love

  1. One can only imagine how those citizens felt walking out of the Library after meeting with the “scientists” who had effectively issued an unofficial boil water advisory to them. What could possibly be more confusing than that combined with threats from new “pathogens” for them to share and tell their friends about.

    And, if one has any doubts about the apparent interest of the team in making others (eg. State officials) look bad, one need only read McElmurry’s seemingly deceptive e-mail to Wells indicating there would be no press there. As in, no big deal; she needn’t worry; just pro forma letting her know. You have to ask yourself…why would someone seem to go out of their way to make another person, who was likely trying hard to rectify the situation in Flint, look bad? Is it because one cannot be a super-hero unless they have demonized every other alternative to themselves??

    It’s a lot to process and take in. Perhaps the answer lies partly in the wording of the 2/6/16 WSU/FACHEP Press release likely written by the team themselves….

    ”In the midst of this maelstrom, a group of engineers along with medical, public health and social scientists assembled a research team to pursue answers to problems that others would rather leave unexamined. The authors of these papers from several universities and members of the research team — which included community members in meaningful roles — affirmed the higher purpose of science — to expand knowledge and serve the common good. As this FACHEP team developed, the key underpinning was the attention to clear, honest communication and careful listening to disenfranchised, marginalized Flint residents.”

    There is something fundamentally wrong about how that statement reads IMO. It smacks of condescending, ingratiating gestures by someone(s) with a superhero mentality. Also, filled with plenty of ‘us against them’. Why stoke more drama in an already stressed community?? It’s baffling.

    At any rate these “scientists” MUST care about the (disenfranchised & marginalized) Flint residents mustn’t they? The scientists were busily testing their water and finding more and more health risks and hazards for them to worry about.

    Who knows what a full $13M budget might have turned up!! Such concern and attention…what’s not to LOVE about that?

    If there was really a secondary public health crisis that’s one thing, if there was not, then these activities could be termed “scientific malpractice”. In which case, the activities of this group remind me more of war profiteers or carpet-baggers rather than “scientists”. It is good that you and the VT team have taken the time to expose this mess, in the hope that vulnerable communities may not be subjected to such activities in the future.

  2. There was a maelstrom, allright, but only the one that they invented.
    More and more, this seems to be an academic equivalent, of firefighter arson.
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Firefighter_arson

    Reconsider FACHEP “hopes” of “impeding the rush to declare the crisis over.” What rush? The 14 months of painstaking engineering progress made before FACHEP lifted a finger? Why is it considered an existential threat, if data shows the water was “improving?”

    And we are wondering, who won over whom: FACHEP won over the activists per Dr. Pauli’s dubious historical account, or the activists won over FACHEP? From this point onwards, it will be shown FACHEP, was virtually indistinguishable from the activists.

    We do support activism. But not the post-truth activism of FACHEP. If they could not handle the truth with a capital “T,” could they at least uphold truth with a lower case “t,” without the outright and self-serving lies?

    And by far the worst is yet to come. One or two more blogs and we can get to it (not counting the trial which will be fascinating now that we know the characters). But you could not possibly believe what happened with FACHEP in Flint 2017-2018, without all of this background. Stay tuned.

    • Hi Marc: “Firefighter arson” is an extremely apt analogy, as is the Dunning-Kruger effect! And I do see 2 definitive acts of psychopathy on the part of Sedgewick. Specifically, deceiving Dr. Faust and misrepresenting her thesis work and products as his own, as well as his cruel toying with the devastated Flint homeowner about the real estate value of his home. Both acts show Sociopathic characteristics listed in the Psychology Today link, specifically, nakedly ambitious, shrewdly exploitative, and ruthlessly aggressive behavior often coupled with an initially charismatic approach with victims before revealing cruel intentions (or professional or profit driven ambitions).

      Whether such an individual (Sedgewick) is capable of imbuing a Group or Organization with these characteristics is a fascinating question. Especially when it’s a group of the Professoriate. However, I feel strongly that we must take Dr. Pauli at his word that he and FACHEP “won-over” the Flint activists; after all, as Dr. Pauli surely knows they (FACHEP) had the PhD’s as well as the need to publish with their ‘subjects’.

      Hence, it seems crystal clear who the victims were in Flint; in fact they had already been primed by the Pb in water crisis, and represented a fertile field for FACHEP to plow.

      I’m looking forward to more details on what led Sedgewick from the apparent heads up from former Wayne State lobbyist Harvey Hollins about the approaching gravy train, to Sedgewick’s aggressively grabbing the Golden Ticket (via Dr. Faust’s work as well as clothing himself in others work/slides), to FACHEP’s role in the post-crisis events in Flint, finally culminating in Sedgewick’s ‘deer in the headlights’ testimony against two State employees (FACHEP’s former state funding minders?).

      I’m really curious about that last step because it seems it would take a lot for a faculty member to possibly perjure themselves, unless, of course, they’re just stupid? How some of these people ended up on a star witness list still in these cases has me still scratching my head.

      Look forward to reading more! And, of course, you know that I am still hoping that Sedgewick is wrong about the World: https://www.wingclips.com/movie-clips/the-emperors-club/who-we-really-are

    • Hmm, a forensic accountant would probably say, follow the money. I suppose a contracting special prosecutor isn’t paid unless he tries cases. And one probably cannot try cases without star witnesses.

      I’m open minded also, and relieved not to be involved; sorting through possible layers of motives could be complicated.

  3. You actually explained this effectively.
    http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
    my canadian pharmacy trust pharmacy canada canadian prescription [url=http://canadianpharmacymim.com/]mexican pharmacies shipping to usa[/url]
    canadian pharmacy no prescription needed
    drugstore online
    web medical information
    prescription drug assistance
    canadian prescription drugstore
    pharmacy drug store

  4. Whoa all kinds of very good information!
    http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
    canada pharmacy online orders canadian viagra my canadian pharmacy [url=http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/]online pharmacies of canada[/url]
    legitimate online pharmacies
    canadian pharmacy king
    canadian discount pharmacy
    canadian pharmacies top best
    pharmacy price compare
    canadapharmacy com

  5. Thanks! Fantastic stuff.
    http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
    us pharmacy no prior prescription canada pharmacy canadian pharmacies that are legit [url=http://canadianpharmacymim.com/]aarp approved canadian online pharmacies[/url]
    canadian pharmacy without prescription
    best canadian prescription prices
    canada pharmacy
    rx online
    best online pharmacy
    prescription drug cost

  6. You actually stated this perfectly.
    http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
    pharmacy near me canadian pharcharmy us pharmacy no prior prescription [url=http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/]canadian pharmacies[/url]
    best canadian pharmacies
    canadian pharmacies that are legit
    discount prescription drug
    price prescription drugs
    no prescription online pharmacy
    online canadian pharmacies

  7. Wonderful write ups. Thanks a lot.
    http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
    prescription drug assistance london drugs canada best online international pharmacies [url=http://talahicc.com/]canadianpharmacy[/url]
    rx online
    canadian pharmacies online
    canadadrugs.com pharmacy
    canadian pharmacy online canada
    canadian pharmacy uk delivery
    mexican pharmacy online

  8. Amazing many of great information!
    http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
    best online pharmacies canada canada drug top rated online canadian pharmacies [url=http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/]canada pharmacy online[/url]
    onlinecanadianpharmacy.com
    prescription drugs online without
    canadian discount pharmacy
    online canadian discount pharmacy
    cheap prescription drugs online
    canadian drug

  9. Amazing lots of great knowledge.
    http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
    buying drugs canada canadian online pharmacy prescription drug cost [url=http://canadianpharmacymim.com/]canadian pharmacies without an rx[/url]
    costco pharmacy pricing
    price prescription drugs
    pain meds online without doctor prescription
    online discount pharmacy
    canadian drug stores online
    online pharmacy no prescription

  10. Cheers. I appreciate it.
    http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
    international pharmacies that ship to the usa canadian pharmacies that ship to us online pharmacy no prescription [url=http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/]canadian online pharmacy[/url]
    best non prescription online pharmacies
    prescription drug assistance
    prescription drug
    costco pharmacy pricing
    canada pharmacies prescription drugs
    prescription drugs without prior prescription

  11. Valuable advice. Thank you!
    http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
    buy online prescription drugs canadian pharmacy online best canadian mail order pharmacies [url=https://nicktambone.com/]canadian pharmaceuticals online[/url]
    canada pharmacy no prescription
    canadian pharmacies without prescriptions
    cialis canadian pharmacy
    canadian prescription
    pharmacy tech
    best non prescription online pharmacies

  12. You suggested that effectively!
    http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
    highest rated canadian pharmacies canadian pharmacies overseas pharmacy forum [url=http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/]canada online pharmacies[/url]
    online canadian pharmacy
    king pharmacy
    canada online pharmacies
    cheap drugs online
    mexican pharmacies
    best canadian pharmacies

  13. Nicely put, Many thanks.
    http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
    best canadian pharmacies canada pharmaceuticals online best canadian prescription prices [url=http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/]northwest pharmacy[/url]
    buy online prescription drugs
    pharmacy drug store
    canada pharmacy online
    pharmacy online mexico
    canada pharmacies
    canada pharmacies without script

  14. Thank you! Good stuff.
    http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
    buy prescription drugs from canada canadian pharmacies online canadian discount pharmacy [url=http://canadianpharmacymim.com/]north west pharmacy canada[/url]
    mail order pharmacy
    canadian prescription drugs
    canadian mail order pharmacies
    prescription drugs online without
    online pharmacies no prescription
    prescription cost comparison

  15. You made your stand very nicely!!
    http://talahicc.com/
    mexican pharmacy online medications canadian pharmacies-24h canadian drugstore online [url=https://nicktambone.com/]canadian pharmacies[/url]
    buy prescription drugs online
    buy prescription drugs online
    canada drug prices
    online pharmacy reviews
    canadianpharmacy
    canada pharmacy online

  16. Incredible a lot of great material.
    http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
    no prescription pharmacy canada pharmaceutical online ordering canadian pharmacies shipping to usa [url=http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/]online pharmacies canada[/url]
    canada pharmacy
    approved canadian pharmacies online
    canada pharmacies online prescriptions
    canada pharmacy online
    buy prescription drugs from canada
    prescription drug assistance

  17. Nicely put, Many thanks!
    https://nicktambone.com/
    best canadian prescription prices canada online pharmacies mexican pharmacy online [url=http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/]canada drug[/url]
    canada pharmacies online
    online drugs
    candrugstore com
    approved canadian pharmacies online
    top rated canadian pharmacies online
    top rated canadian pharmacies online

  18. Many thanks. Numerous facts.
    http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
    canadian drugs northwest pharmacy canadian family pharmacy [url=http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/]canadian pharmacies[/url]
    prescription pricing
    international pharmacies that ship to the usa
    cheap canadian drugs
    canadian drug stores online
    best canadian prescription prices
    internet pharmacy

  19. Helpful knowledge. Cheers.
    http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
    trust pharmacy canada canada online pharmacies pharmacy cost comparison [url=http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/]canadian pharmacies-24h[/url]
    online canadian pharmacy
    canadian pharmacy king
    best online international pharmacies
    mexican online pharmacies
    best online pharmacies canada
    candrugstore com

  20. You actually said that really well.
    http://talahicc.com/
    canadian prescription drugs northwestpharmacy canada pharmacies prescription drugs [url=http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/]canadian pharmacies[/url]
    canadian pharmacy 365
    canadian rx pharmacy online
    24 hour pharmacy
    online pharmacy canada
    canadian online pharmacy reviews
    pharmacy prescription

  21. Amazing material. Thank you.
    http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
    best online international pharmacies canadian pharmacies-24h canadian prescription drugs [url=http://talahicc.com/]trust pharmacy canada[/url]
    online canadian pharmacy
    canadian pharmacy no prescription
    prescription drugs prices
    mail order pharmacy
    pharmacy online store
    approved canadian pharmacies online

  22. You actually stated this adequately.
    http://talahicc.com/
    prescription drugs canada canada pharmaceuticals online buy prescription drugs online [url=http://talahicc.com/]canadian online pharmacy[/url]
    canadian rx
    canadian online pharmacies prescription drugs
    canada pharmacies
    prescription pricing
    pharmacy online store
    prescription drugs prices

  23. You actually revealed that really well!
    http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
    canadian pharmacy king canada pharmacy online pharmacies no prescription [url=http://canadianpharmacymim.com/]canadian pharmacies without an rx[/url]
    onlinecanadianpharmacy.com
    drug costs
    prescription price comparison
    pharmacy price compare
    costco pharmacy pricing
    mexican online pharmacies

  24. Really a good deal of amazing facts.
    http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
    prescription drug cost canada online pharmacies mexican online pharmacies [url=https://nicktambone.com/]london drugs canada[/url]
    canadian mail order pharmacies
    canadian prescription
    canadapharmacy
    buying drugs canada
    canadian online pharmacy reviews
    canadian cialis

  25. Helpful posts. Appreciate it.
    http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
    canadian cialis canadian pharmacy online discount pharmacy [url=http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/]canadian pharcharmy[/url]
    online canadian pharcharmy
    drugs online
    canadian pharcharmy online
    pain meds online without doctor prescription
    drugs online
    pharmacy price compare

  26. Nicely put. With thanks!
    http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
    buy online prescription drugs canada pharmacy canada online pharmacy [url=http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/]canadian pharmacies online[/url]
    canadian drugstore online
    mexican pharmacies
    online pharmacy no prescription
    northwestpharmacy
    highest rated canadian pharmacies
    canadian drug store

  27. Amazing info, Thanks a lot.
    http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
    meds online canada pharmacy online canada pharmacies online prescriptions [url=http://talahicc.com/]aarp approved canadian online pharmacies[/url]
    canadian pharmacies without prescriptions
    rx price comparison
    drugs for sale
    rx online
    reputable canadian mail order pharmacies
    ed meds online

  28. Truly plenty of awesome data.
    http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
    prescription drugs prices canada pharmaceuticals online canadian drug stores online [url=http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/]canadian online pharmacy[/url]
    pharmacy prices compare
    pharmacy prescription
    prescription price comparison
    rx pharmacy
    canada online pharmacies
    pharmacy online

  29. Wow all kinds of beneficial advice.
    http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
    prescription cost canadian pharmacies without an rx prescription drug cost [url=http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/]aarp approved canadian online pharmacies[/url]
    buying prescription drugs canada
    cheap prescription drugs online
    safeway pharmacy
    online pharmacy no prescription needed
    canadian drug store
    prescription cost comparison

  30. Thanks a lot. Useful stuff!
    http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
    the canadian pharmacy canadian online pharmacy canadian pharmacy no prescription needed [url=http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/]canada pharmaceutical online ordering[/url]
    best canadian online pharmacy
    canadian pharmacy without prescription
    prescription price comparison
    overseas pharmacy forum
    pharmacy near me
    online pharmacy canada

  31. Useful facts. Cheers!
    http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
    northwestpharmacy aarp approved canadian online pharmacies mexican pharmacy online [url=http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/]canada pharmacy online[/url]
    canadian pharmacy reviews
    canada pharmacies online
    canadian pharmacy viagra
    canada pharmacy no prescription
    pharmacy price compare
    canada drug

  32. You expressed it adequately.
    http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
    canadian pharmacy viagra brand canada pharmaceutical online ordering canada pharmacies without script [url=http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/]canadian online pharmacy[/url]
    canada meds
    prescription cost comparison
    trusted overseas pharmacies
    online canadian pharcharmy
    pharmacy near me
    drugs online

  33. This is nicely said. .
    http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
    overseas pharmacy forum global pharmacy canada prescription drug price comparison [url=http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/]canadianpharmacy[/url]
    canadapharmacy
    canadian family pharmacy
    canada pharmacy
    canadian online pharmacy reviews
    canadian pharmacy no prescription needed
    prescription cost

  34. Really many of useful information!
    http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
    canada pharmacies without script canadianpharmacy online pharmacy without a prescription [url=http://talahicc.com/]top rated canadian pharmacies online[/url]
    prescription without a doctor’s prescription
    canadian rx pharmacy online
    best online pharmacy
    pharmacy canada
    online rx pharmacy
    canadian online pharmacy reviews

  35. Reliable facts. Thanks.
    http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
    canada pharmacy no prescription canadian drugs pharmacy price compare [url=http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/]london drugs canada[/url]
    canadian online pharmacies
    pain meds online without doctor prescription
    online prescription drugs
    canada drugs online
    best online pharmacy stores
    pharmacy without dr prescriptions

  36. Amazing lots of awesome tips!
    http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
    cialis canadian pharmacy canada drugs online mexican pharmacy online medications [url=http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/]canadian pharmacy online[/url]
    get prescription online
    mexican pharmacies
    prescription online
    canadian pharmacy
    prescription drug
    canadian pharmacy no prescription needed

  37. You suggested it wonderfully!
    http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
    pharmacies in canada canada drugs online online canadian pharmacy [url=http://canadianpharmacymim.com/]top rated canadian pharmacies online[/url]
    canada drug prices
    canada pharmacies online pharmacy
    canadian family pharmacy
    web medical information
    pharmacies in canada
    ed meds online

  38. You actually stated that adequately!
    http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
    international pharmacies that ship to the usa london drugs canada canadian meds [url=http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/]mexican pharmacies shipping to usa[/url]
    cheap prescription drugs
    board of pharmacy
    pharmacy near me
    drugs for sale
    cialis canadian pharmacy
    board of pharmacy

  39. Cheers! Very good stuff.
    http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
    visit poster’s website canadian pharmacy canadian pharmacy online canada [url=http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/]canadian pharmacy[/url]
    discount prescription drugs online
    costco pharmacy pricing
    prescription cost comparison
    canada drug pharmacy
    canadian cialis
    prescription drugs without doctor approval

  40. You explained this terrifically.
    https://nicktambone.com/
    canadian pharmacy without prescription trust pharmacy canada northwestpharmacy [url=http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/]canada pharmaceutical online ordering[/url]
    canadian pharmacy viagra brand
    no prescription pharmacies
    canada drugs online
    prescription online
    drugstore online
    canadian pharmacies that ship to us

  41. You suggested this adequately.
    http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
    pharmacy price comparison aarp approved canadian online pharmacies board of pharmacy [url=http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/]online pharmacies of canada[/url]
    mail order pharmacies
    canadian prescriptions
    canadian pharmacies top best
    mexican pharmacies online
    canada pharmacies
    canada pharmacy online

  42. Superb data. Many thanks.
    http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
    drug stores near me mexican pharmacies shipping to usa canadian mail order pharmacies [url=http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/]global pharmacy canada[/url]
    canadian pharmacy without prescription
    canada drug
    best canadian prescription prices
    drugstore online
    canadian pharmacy online
    canadadrugs

  43. Whoa a lot of valuable facts!
    http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
    best canadian prescription prices canadian pharmaceuticals online prescription prices comparison [url=http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/]canada online pharmacies[/url]
    canadian pharmacy viagra brand
    rx pharmacy
    prescription price comparison
    northwest pharmacy
    ed meds online
    best online pharmacy stores

  44. Really loads of wonderful data!
    http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
    canadian pharmacy viagra canada pharmaceutical online ordering trusted overseas pharmacies [url=http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/]canadian pharmacies[/url]
    best online pharmacy
    canadapharmacyonline.com
    online canadian discount pharmacy
    online rx pharmacy
    canada drug pharmacy
    canadian prescriptions

  45. Excellent data. Regards.
    http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
    canada pharmacy online no script canada pharmacy prescription drugs online without doctor [url=http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/]canadian cialis[/url]
    online prescription drugs
    canadapharmacy
    canada pharmacies
    canada pharmacy online
    buy prescription drugs online
    prescription drugs online without doctor

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *