We previously noted the high corrosivity of Flint River water to iron pipe, and the higher incidence of red water and pipe leaks as a result, when compared to the use of Detroit water. At the time, we also mentioned that the Flint River water is much more corrosive to lead plumbing. Scientifically, this is because Flint River has much higher chloride content, which leaches lead from plumbing materials into drinking water.
Experiment: When we visited Flint, we took copper pipe pieces joined with lead solder (old solder is 50% lead by weight) inside them. Lead solder is probably present in plumbing systems of many Detroit/Flint homes built before 1986 when it was banned from use in drinking water systems. We put the lead solder-copper pipe test pieces in 250 mL containers, and filled them with the following three waters:
Test 1) Detroit water
Test 2) Current Flint River water
Test 3) Current Flint River water with orthophosphate (a typical corrosion inhibitor)
Test 3 was conducted, to see if adding orthophosphate to Flint River water would stop lead corrosion.
The first thing we noticed was that waters in Test 2 and Test 3 (with Flint River water added) started turning white because of significantly high lead corrosion occurring in them (Figure 1, left). In contrast, Detroit water in the exact same test (Test 1) remained clear (Figure 1, right). Three identical tests are currently being run for aforementioned Tests 1-3 to provide replication increase confidence in the results (only two containers shown in Figure 1).
We then collected water samples from every container at the end of Weeks 1 and 2. This means, for each test we took a total of 6 samples. We then used statistics to see what conclusions we could make with confidence.
The Detroit water is clearly much less corrosive to lead solder than the Flint River water. On average, Detroit water is 12 times (or 12X) less corrosive than the Flint River water currently in use. That is, the current Flint River water leaches 12X more lead to the water than Detroit water. This explains why the lead in Flint’s water in our survey, is so high, even when it was low before when Detroit water was being used.
Unfortunately, it does not look like orthophosphate is helping to stop lead leaching when in contact with Flint River water, which is also consistent with expectations based on experiments in high chloride water. There is a slight improvement, but even with phosphate, Flint River water has 10 times more lead compared to the same condition using Detroit water. We will continue to run these tests to see if orthophosphate starts reducing the lead present in the test with Flint River water.
Conclusion: On a scientific basis, Flint River water leaches more lead from plumbing than does Detroit water as predicted before. This is creating a public health threat in some Flint homes that have lead pipe or lead solder. Unfortunately, adding orthophosphate corrosion inhibitor to the Flint River water, does not solve the lead problem (at least based on the first two weeks of testing).
Experiments and analysis: Christina Devine
Primary Author: Dr. Marc Edwards
Acknowledgements: Siddhartha Roy
[…] are now three weeks into our laboratory experiment w.r.t. testing the relative corrosivity of Flint River water versus Detroi…. As the test continues, it becomes a more accurate measure of the relative corrosivity of the two […]
[…] battered Flint switched its water source from Lake Huron to the less-expensive Flint River. Researchers at Virginia Tech say the new water is more corrosive and is leaching lead from pipes into the drinking water. After the […]
[…] economically smashed Flint switched a H2O source from Lake Huron to a less-expensive Flint River. Researchers during Virginia Tech say the new H2O is some-more erosive and is leaching lead from pipes into a celebration water. After […]
[…] battered Flint switched its water source from Lake Huron to the less-expensive Flint River. Researchers at Virginia Tech say the new water is more corrosive and is leaching lead from pipes into the drinking water. After […]
[…] battered Flint switched its water source from Lake Huron to the less-expensive Flint River. Researchers at Virginia Tech say the new water is more corrosive and is leaching lead from pipes into the drinking water. After […]
[…] The problem begins when corrosive water enters these pipes and dissolves the lead. One of the most important contributors to this corrosion is simple salt and, every winter, immense quantities of salt are spread on the Michigan roads, some of which finds its way into the Flint River. […]
[…] The problem begins when corrosive water enters these pipes and dissolves the lead. One of the most important contributors to this corrosion is simple salt and, every winter, immense quantities of salt are spread on the Michigan roads, some of which finds its way into the Flint River. […]
[…] Researchers said Flint River water is much more corrosive, causing lead from the city’s distribution system to leech into it. Independent investigations have found elevated lead levels in the city’s water and high blood lead levels in some children. […]
[…] economically smashed Flint switched a H2O source from Lake Huron to a less-expensive Flint River. Researchers during Virginia Tech say the new H2O is some-more erosive and is leaching lead from pipes into a celebration water. After […]
[…] The problem begins when corrosive water enters these pipes and dissolves the lead. One of the most important contributors to this corrosion is simple salt and, every winter, immense quantities of salt are spread on the Michigan roads, some of which finds its way into the Flint River. […]
[…] water system in October, but the damage was done. Water from the Flint River was found to be highly corrosive to the lead pipes still used in some parts of the city. Even though Flint River water no longer flows through the […]
[…] water system in October, but the damage was done. Water from the Flint River was found to be highly corrosive to the lead pipes still used in some parts of the city. Even though Flint River water no longer flows through the […]